The number sellers say out loud is the list price. The number that lands in the bank account is smaller, sometimes by a little and sometimes by enough to change the plan the money was supposed to fund. The gap is not a trick. It is a stack of line items nobody added up before the sign went in the yard.
Run the estimate before you list, while every option is still open. Once the house is on the market, the meter is running and the math gets harder to change.
I am Jesse Wyatt, owner of Synergy Redevelopers, LLC in Jacksonville. I buy houses directly from sellers all over Florida, which means I sit on the other side of this worksheet most weeks. Here is how I would estimate what you actually keep, bucket by bucket, with one honest example at the end. Quick note: I am not a lawyer or a tax professional, and this is not legal or tax advice. It is arithmetic.

Bucket 1: the mortgage payoff
Start with what you owe, and get the real figure. The balance on your last statement is not the payoff. The payoff adds interest through the closing date, and it counts everything secured by the house: the first mortgage, a home equity line you drew on three years ago, a second loan from the kitchen remodel.
Call the servicer and request a payoff quote good through your expected closing date. That number is the biggest single line in the whole estimate, and guessing at it poisons everything below it. If there are other liens, old judgments, a tax issue, those come out of your side too, and a title search will find them whether you look first or not. Better to look first.
Bucket 2: commissions, if you list
List the house and this is the largest cost after the payoff. Total commission typically runs 5 to 6 percent of the sale price, and recent national surveys of agents put the average around 5.5 to 5.7 percent, split roughly evenly between your listing agent and the buyer’s agent.
The ground shifted in August 2024. Under the NAR settlement rules, what the buyer’s agent gets paid is no longer baked into the listing. It gets negotiated inside each offer, and many sellers still pay it as a concession to keep the buyer pool wide. Some do not. Either way, on a $350,000 sale the difference between a 5 percent total and a 6 percent total is $3,500, so this line is worth a direct conversation with any agent before you sign, not after.
Sell directly to a cash buyer and this bucket is zero. There is no listing agent because there is no listing. On my purchases there is no service fee either. Hold that thought until the example, because zero commission is not the same thing as more money. It depends what the price does.
Bucket 3: Florida seller closing costs
These are the state and local line items, and in Florida they are real money even though each one looks small.
Documentary stamp tax on the deed. Florida taxes the deed at $0.70 for every $100 of the sale price, and the seller customarily pays it. That is $2,450 on a $350,000 sale. (Miami-Dade runs its own rate, $0.60 per $100 plus a surtax on most non single family transfers. Jacksonville is $0.70.)
Owner’s title insurance policy. Florida sets this premium by law, so it is the same at every title company: $5.75 per $1,000 of price on the first $100,000, then $5.00 per $1,000 above that. On $350,000 it comes to $1,825. In Duval County and most of Florida the seller customarily pays it and picks the title company. A few South Florida counties flip that custom to the buyer, which is one more reason the contract, not habit, decides who pays what.
Prorated property taxes. Florida taxes are paid in arrears, so at closing you owe the buyer a credit for the part of the year you owned the house. On a typical Jacksonville tax bill that is often a couple of thousand dollars at a mid year closing. Your last tax bill tells you the annual number; divide by 365 and multiply by the days from January 1 to your closing date for a close estimate.
The small stuff. Settlement and recording charges, a lien search, an HOA or condo estoppel letter if your community charges for one. Budget a few hundred dollars.
Add it up and a Florida seller’s closing costs, before any commission, commonly land around 1 to 3 percent of the price.
Bucket 4: repairs and concessions
This is the bucket sellers underestimate, because it arrives in two separate hits.
The first hit is getting ready: the handyman list, the deep clean, the pressure washing, maybe carpet or paint so the photos look right. The second hit comes after the buyer’s inspection, when their agent sends over a repair request or asks for a credit instead. Roofs, older electrical panels, and aging HVAC systems are the usual Jacksonville items, and a financed buyer means a lender and an appraiser get a say as well. A house sold as-is skips most of this, and I wrote up what as-is actually covers in a separate piece, but skipping the repairs does not make them free. The buyer prices them into the offer instead.
Bucket 5: the cost of the months in between
A listed sale takes time: prep, showings, an offer, inspections, the buyer’s loan, closing. While that runs, you are still paying the mortgage, the taxes, the insurance, and the power bill on a house you have already decided to leave. Three months of carrying costs on a typical Jacksonville mortgage can run $5,000 to $7,000. It never appears on the closing statement as a line, which is exactly why people forget to count it. Count it.
A worked example, with the assumptions on the table
This is a hypothetical, built with round numbers so you can check my math. Same house both routes: a Jacksonville house that could list at $350,000, with a mortgage payoff of $185,000.
Route 1: list it at $350,000, and it sells at full price.
- Sale price: $350,000
- Commissions at 5.5 percent: minus $19,250
- Documentary stamps on the deed: minus $2,450
- Owner’s title policy: minus $1,825
- Repairs and cleanup before listing: minus $4,500
- Credit to the buyer after inspection: minus $3,000
- Prorated property taxes: minus $1,950
- Settlement, recording, and miscellaneous: minus $650
- Mortgage payoff: minus $185,000
- Estimated proceeds: $131,375
Route 2: sell it to me as-is at $295,000.
- Cash price: $295,000
- Commissions: $0
- Service fee: $0
- Repairs and cleanup: $0, the house sells as it sits
- Documentary stamps on the deed: minus $2,065
- Owner’s title policy: minus $1,550
- Settlement and recording: minus $450
- Prorated property taxes: minus $1,950
- Mortgage payoff: minus $185,000
- Estimated proceeds: $103,985
Read the result honestly. On these assumptions the listed route keeps about $27,390 more, and I will not pretend otherwise. If your house is retail ready and you have a season to spare, listing is usually the money winner, and the worksheet is how you prove it to yourself instead of taking my word for it.
Now read the assumptions just as honestly. Route 1 needs the full $350,000. A 5 percent price cut during the listing takes $17,500 off the top before costs. It needs the repair hits to stay at $7,500 combined; an old roof found at inspection changes that fast. And it does not count the carrying costs above, roughly $6,000 over a three month stretch on this example, which narrows the real gap to somewhere near $21,000. Route 2’s number is lower and it is also close to final the day we sign: no showings, no lender, no appraisal, and on a clean title I can close in as little as 7 days, with 7 to 21 days typical. Your closing costs on a sale to me are itemized in the written agreement before you sign anything, and my offer comes after a walkthrough, with the math shown, so you can hold it next to this worksheet line by line. The steps are on my how we buy houses page.
How to run your own estimate this week
Get the payoff quote from your servicer. Pull last year’s tax bill. Ask any agent you interview for a written net sheet at your expected price, not a verbal range, and ask what commission structure they are assuming. Then get at least one cash number in writing and compare proceeds to proceeds, never price to price. The estimate takes an afternoon. The listing takes a season. Do them in that order.
If you want the second set of numbers for your house, call me at (904) 867-8673 or start at sell my house fast in Jacksonville. One walkthrough, one written offer, and if the worksheet says listing wins on your house, you will hear that from me.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between sale price and proceeds?
The sale price is what the buyer pays. Your proceeds are what is left after the mortgage payoff, commissions, closing costs, and any credits come out. On a listed Florida sale, the commissions and closing costs alone commonly run 7 to 10 percent of the price, and the payoff comes out on top of that.
How much are seller closing costs in Florida without commission?
Commonly about 1 to 3 percent of the price. The big pieces are the documentary stamp tax on the deed ($0.70 per $100, seller’s cost by custom) and the owner’s title insurance policy at the state set rate, plus prorated taxes and smaller title charges. Your contract decides who pays each item.
Do I pay commission if I sell to a cash buyer?
No. Commission exists because agents listed and marketed the house. A direct sale has no listing, and on my purchases there is no service fee charged to the seller either. The trade is the price: a cash offer reflects the repairs and risk the buyer takes on, which is why comparing net proceeds, not prices, is the only fair test.
Can I get an estimate before I talk to anyone?
Yes, most of it. Your payoff quote and your tax bill give you the two biggest lines for free. What you cannot get alone is a real market number for your specific house, which is why a written agent net sheet and a written cash offer, side by side, beat any online calculator.